- Data flows
- Who can access the data
- Audit logs
- Data security at rest
- Data security in transit
- Data archival, retention, and disposal
- Electronic signature
For a Concentric deployment where demographic and document integrations are in place, the diagram shows the key data flows between users (clinicians and patients) and systems.
Who can access the data
All clinician users can access patient data used, restricted to their healthcare organisation, and use this access to create and edit consent episodes. Nurses and theatre staff are provided with equivalent access to the patient data used, and will typically use the platform to check that consent has been given.
Authentication and authorisation of all users is via either a healthcare organisation managed authentication service or by managing healthcare organisation specific Concentric Health user accounts on behalf of the healthcare organisation.
Functional limitations are not enforced for different healthcare professional users within the healthcare organisation, with each subject to professional guidelines regarding professionalism and scope of practice.
Patients are sent an email and/or SMS message containing an unguessable link which allows them to securely view their consent record, including if appropriate, the ability to give consent remotely. This message is shared at the completion of each interaction with a clinician. Messages are sent using GDPR compliant external email/SMS services, and contain no special category data. Full patient authentication and security details are within the technical description document.
Concentric Health staff
We take protecting patient data extremely seriously.
We have applied the following principles while designing Concentric:
- Access to patient data, by both humans and systems, should be minimised.
- Technical solutions which prevent access to data are preferred to policies.
- All access to patient data should be auditable, with strong guarantees that prevent these controls being circumvented.
By minimising the systems responsible for the storage and access to patient details, we reduce the scope for any bugs, reduce the attack surface area, reduce the number of employees with access, and can increase the scrutiny applied to changes to these systems.
We encapsulate the storage of patient details within a service dedicated to this purpose. It ensures (cryptographically) that at an application level only clinicians logged in to the appropriate tenant (i.e. healthcare organisation) can access a patient record, or the patient themselves, and that all access to patient records is audit logged to an append only structure.
These security critical services are only accessible to a subset of the engineering team. Again this access is protected by cryptographic controls.
In order to allow us to diagnose issues with a specific tenant (e.g. a healthcare organisation), the Concentric authorization service allows specific individuals (GMC-registered clinicians with license to practice) to authorise themselves to the system as if they were clinical staff logged in to a specific tenant, using dedicated login details designed for this purpose. Their access to patient details is auditable via exactly the same mechanism as for any other users. At a policy level this is considered an exceptional use case.
Consent episodes are stored as an immutable sequence of changes, with each change linked to a logged in user, allowing application level auditing of changes. All access to patient data is logged against the authenticated user id. Application logs are also written, which identify the authenticated user.
Concentric is an internet accessible application, hosted on Google Cloud Platform (GCP), with the appropriate data centre location used for each healthcare organisation (e.g. UK NHS Trust data is held within a UK data centre). GCP are fully compliant with NHS information governance requirements.
The cloud deployment at each data centre is multi-tenant, so each healthcare organisation uses the same physical deployment. Within the multi-tenant system, care is taken to ensure that users logged in to one tenant can only access data linked to that tenant. This is done, for example, by including the patient’s tenant in a cryptographically signed auth_token, and operating internal services under zero-trust principles.
Data security at rest
Personal and episode data is stored in a relational database (PostgreSQL), which stores its data at rest on an encrypted (using AES-256) distributed block storage device. The database operates in master-slave configuration for redundancy, and additionally backup snapshots (also AES-256 encrypted) are taken periodically for disaster recovery. All database block data is logically protected by access control lists (ACLs) which limit access to the appropriate database servers.
Legal consent PDFs are stored in a distributed block storage device which encrypts data using AES-256 before it is written to disk.
Data security in transit
Web and API servers only allow requests made using TLS version 1.2 or above, which provides protection against snooping and man in the middle attacks on data.
Non-HTTPS requests are denied by API servers.
Data archival, retention, and disposal
All data relating to consent episodes is stored for a specified number of years as dictated by the individual healthcare organisation as the data controller. Concentric Health recommends that this time period is at least 8 years, as per best practice for electronic health record data. After the agreed number of years of full data retention, the data is reduced to a stub record containing patient details, procedure name, date, and responsible clinician.
Backups are designed for data recovery, and are stored for 30 days. Data is not removed from backups when removing patient or consent data, but will naturally expire.
Data Security Protection Toolkit
The system, and business processes, have been assessed to exceed the standards required by the NHS Digital Data Security Protection Toolkit (DSPT). The assessment is available to view here.
Cyber Essentials Plus
The company is certified to meet Cyber Essentials Plus standards for cyber security.
As per the UK eIDAS Regulation, the UK’s electronic signature regulation, a digital signature can be obtained, by method of an on-screen signature, and is court-admissible.
The digital signature captured by the Concentric Health digital consent platforms conforms to the requirements of an Advanced Electronic Signature (AES), meeting the requirements that it is uniquely linked to the signatory, is capable of identifying the signatory, creation is under the control of the signatory, and the completed signature is stored in a way that subsequent change to the data, either signature data or information viewed by the signatory, is detectable.